Then take it to your local Dollar Tree to get it for 25 cents. Not all stores will necessarily have this in stock, but it’s worth a shot.
Otherwise, use the $.75/1 Smucker’s Toppings coupon to save $1.50 at a store that doubles. I’m going to pick up some Caramel Topping for some holiday cooking. It’s in an ingredient in many of the dessert recipes I’ve seen lately.